Whole day depends on check-in timing
Contingency plan
Plan: email Sand Hotel on 9/28 requesting early check-in (see Pre-Trip To-Do box), then call the front desk once you've landed to confirm actual timing. If check-in is late (3pm): do everything below to stay busy. If check-in comes early (e.g. noon): cut down to just breakfast + the church walk, then go check in and rest instead of forcing the rest of the list. Priority order if cutting: 1) Breakfast (non-negotiable, everyone eats) 2) Church walk (low effort, right there) 3) Grótta (first to cut — adds real drive time) 4) Wine/cheese errand (second to cut — can shift to another day since Vínbúðin exists elsewhere too).
6:15 AM
Land at KEF
Confirmed
Passport control + bags ≈30 min. Iceland is Schengen — manual passport line, not e-gates, if arriving direct from the US.
≈7:00 AM
Pick up rental car — Blue Car Rental
Confirmed
Confirmed · Kia Cee'd Sportswagon, automatic
Not a driving direction, a walking one: from arrivals, walk toward the Departures Hall side, then cross the P1 parking lot (~3–4 min) to Blikavöllur 3. Bring booking confirmation, driver's license, credit card in Mike's name. Do online check-in before you fly to speed this up.
≈8:00 AM
P4
Breakfast — Sandholt
Plan
Sandholt — SAND-holt
Opens 7:30 AM. Right at the hotel (Laugavegur 36, two doors from Sand Hotel at 34) — lamb sandwiches, pastries, good coffee. Grab a couple extra pastries/bakery items to go — easy casual lunch for today or another day.
≈8:45 AM
P3
Walk: Skólavörðustígur → Hallgrímskirkja
Plan
Hallgrímskirkja — HATL-greems-KIRK-ya · Skólavörðustígur — SKOH-la-vur-thu-stee-gur
Rainbow Street up to the church, ~4-5 min each way from the hotel. Easy, flat, good for a jet-lagged morning. Optional elevator up the tower for a city view. Loop back to the car afterward.
≈9:30 AM
P4
Drive to Grótta Lighthouse
Plan — tide dependent
Grótta — GROH-tah
~10–15 min drive. Causeway only walkable at low tide. Sept 29 low tide ≈1:53 PM — causeway should be crossable roughly 10:30 AM–4:30 PM, so a ~9:30 AM departure lines up well. Check conditions on arrival; wind can affect water levels beyond the standard prediction. Free parking on site.
≈11:00 AM
P5
Vínbúðin (wine) + Bónus or Krónan (cheese, crackers)
Plan — errand run
Vínbúðin — VEEN-boo-thin · Bónus — BOH-nus · Krónan — KROH-nan
Drive back toward downtown. Vínbúðin (state liquor monopoly — the only place wine is sold) opens around 11am weekdays. Wine: ask staff for "unoaked chardonnay" directly (most speak English), or look for Chablis (French Chardonnay, traditionally unoaked/steel-fermented) or a New World bottle explicitly labeled "unoaked" on the front. Pair with a stop at Krónan, Hallveigarstígur for an easy finger-food spread: harðfiskur (dried fish, eaten with butter — genuinely iconic, protein-rich, easy to snack on), thin-sliced hangikjöt (smoked lamb, works like charcuterie), Icelandic cheeses, flatkökur or rúgbrauð (flatbread/rye bread), and crackers. Regular supermarkets only sell low-alcohol beer, not wine, so both stops are needed. Do this before parking for the day, not after.
15:00 (asking earlier)
Park for the day & check in — Sand Hotel
Confirmed
Confirmed · Deluxe Room · 2 nights
No hotel parking — nearest paid lot is ~25m away, €25/day, staffed 9 AM–6 PM (confirm with hotel whether overnight/in-out access works, since you'll want the car early on 10/1). Park here once errands are done, not before. Standard check-in 3 PM; front desk is 24/7 and will hold bags earlier. Following up directly to ask about a paid early check-in (~$50) around 10 AM. Laundry: hotel offers drop-off/valet service, priced per item (socks ~$1.34/pair, shirts ~$4.32 — far cheaper than US hotel laundry). Even better: Wash Laundromat at Grettisgata 3 is genuine self-service, right on the same street as the hotel — ~$6.50/wash (up to 10kg) and ~$6.50/dry, so a full load runs ~$13. Elevator: yes.
Evening
P4
Dinner — Íslenski Barinn (The Icelandic Bar)
Leaning toward this — no reservation
Íslenski Barinn — EES-len-skee BAH-rin
~7-10 min walk from Sand Hotel, on Ingólfsstræti just off Laugavegur. Casual, lively pub serving real Icelandic dishes — no reservations, rarely more than a 10 min wait. Order this: the gratinated fish pie (haddock, onion, cheese, béarnaise) or the lamb shank — both consistently praised. Kjötsúpa (lamb soup) is the safe, comforting option. Heads up: the menu also includes whale and puffin (marinated fin whale on the sharing board, a puffin skonsa sandwich) — per the food guide, both are worth thinking twice about rather than ordering by default.